Morning Call: The Macbeth Budget
Morning Call: The Macbeth Budget
Why Rachel Reeves has decided that tax rises are best done quickly.
Good morning, George here.
Rachel Reeves will today deliver the first Labour Budget for 14 years and the first-ever by a female chancellor. It’s a major moment in the UK’s history – even before Reeves has uttered a word. Below I explore what will define her statement.
To enjoy our latest analysis of politics, news and events, in addition to world-class literary and cultural reviews, click here to subscribe to the New Statesman. You’ll enjoy all of the New Statesman’s online content, ad-free podcasts and invitations to NS events.
During the general election campaign, Rachel Reeves appeared trapped in a straitjacket of her own making. By pledging not to raise income tax, National Insurance, VAT and corporation tax, she had ruled out deploying the taxes that account for more than two-thirds of government revenue.
Reeves had also bound herself to fiscal rules that radically limited the scope for investment. In order to meet her promise to reduce government debt as a share of GDP, Labour’s manifesto offered just £4.7bn of extra capital spending. Economists scoffed at its fiscal modesty: call this a growth plan?
But today, in an act of political escapology, Reeves will break free of these constraints. First, she will increase employers’ National Insurance as part of what some predict will be the biggest tax-raising Budget in history (the current record was set by Norman Lamont in 1993). Mindful that this may be her moment of maximum political leverage, Reeves has moved swiftly. Call it the Macbeth Budget: “If it were done when ’tis done, then ’twere well it were done quickly” (as is said of the murder of King Duncan).
The charge that Reeves faces is that she has killed one of Labour’s manifesto pledges. Party aides reject this claim, recalling that the Tories challenged them during the election to rule out an increase in employers’ NI (they didn’t). But what Reeves can’t deny is that this is a tax on business and, indirectly, “working people” – the criticism that she made of Rishi Sunak’s NI increase back in 2022. Expect the Chancellor to argue that the Conservatives’ profligacy left her with no choice. The facts have changed, so she has changed her mind.
Reeves’s second escape act is over borrowing. As first trailed a month ago in her Labour conference speech, the Chancellor will revise her debt rule to create more room for investment. Reeves is set to adopt a measure known as public sector net financial liabilities (PSNFL), which takes into account government assets – such as the student loan book and company shares. This would free up £50bn for investment, but Reeves is expected to settle for around £20bn to reassure the markets. She will also vow not to borrow for day-to-day spending (something that could necessitate future tax rises).
The Chancellor hopes that her extensive pitch-rolling will prevent anything resembling a Truss-style backlash. But more than Sunak’s Budget response – his last major act as leader of the opposition – eyes will be fixed on UK gilt yields (already at a post-election high).
Reeves’s wager is that the short-term pain of tax rises will be offset by the long-term gain of improved public services. This, polls suggest, is what voters expect from a Labour government. The nightmare for Reeves will come if the Conservatives can credibly argue that voters are “paying more for less”. That’s one reason the debate over public sector spending – and reform – is only just beginning.
NS event
Join the New Statesman for the NS Budget Briefing, as we dissect the Autumn Budget with insight from journalists, industry experts and policymakers. Our line-up of expert speakers includes: Will Dunn, business editor of the New Statesman, Dr Jeevun Sandher, MP for Loughborough, Satvir Kaur, MP for Southampton Test, Gillian Cooper, executive director of partnerships and advocacy at Citizens Advice, and Paul Morris, head of government affairs, Vodafone. Together they will examine the measures put forward by the Chancellor and what they tell us about Labour’s plans to drive economic growth.
We will also investigate how Labour could tackle the £40bn “black hole” in the UK’s public finances and how the Treasury can find solutions that will fix the foundations of the British economy.
The NS Budget Briefing is hosted in association with Vodafone, and will take place in Westminster at 18.30 tonight, 30 October.
NS Budget Briefing tickets usually cost:
➤ Briefing Pass: £14.95 inc VAT
➤ NS Subscriber Briefing Pass: £7.95 inc VAT
Please get in touch with events@newstatesman.co.uk for more information.
IN ASSOCIATION WITH:
George’s picks
David Gauke asks whether Labour will pay for its inconsistency on tax and spend.
Freddie explores how podcasts are shaping the US presidential election.
Katie Stallard on the real danger of sending North Korean troops to Ukraine.
Andrew reviews the life of Claud Cockburn, the original guerrilla journalist.
For ambulance services, the speed they respond to somebody having a cardiac arrest can mean the difference between life and death. That’s why the Welsh Ambulance Service is working with the University of Warwick and industry partner SkyBound – who use DJI drones – to explore the drone-based delivery of defibrillators. This approach is already used in Sweden, and can allow the patient to receive potentially life-saving treatment before an ambulance arrives. See more
And with that…
Let me know what you think about today’s Morning Call by hitting reply. My thanks to Zoë Huxford.
Have a great day; we’ll have further Budget coverage this afternoon from myself, Andrew Marr, Rachel Cunliffe, David Gauke, Will Dunn, and Megan Kenyon.
George — @georgeeaton