Good morning. In eight days’ time, France could have its first hard-right government since the Second World War. President Emmanuel Macron’s gamble to call an early parliamentary election has not paid off. Yesterday’s first round vote saw Marine Le Pen’s National Rally move into first place, with the left-wing New Popular Front in second and Macron’s Ensemble trailing in third.
If Macron and the left cannot agree to prioritise candidates with the best chance of beating the National Rally before the second round on Sunday, then Le Pen’s protégé Jordan Bardella could become Macron’s prime minister. The best Macron’s camp can hope for is to deprive the National Rally of an outright majority. France’s options look grim: gridlock or the hard right in government.
To enjoy our latest election news and analysis with unlimited access to our coverage, click here to subscribe to the New Statesman. You’ll enjoy all of the New Statesman’s online content, ad-free podcasts and invitations to NS events.
The National Rally’s success corresponds with a broader rise in the nationalist right across Europe. Today, Viktor Orbán’s Hungary has taken up the EU presidency, promising to “Make Europe Great Again”. The European parliamentary elections in June saw the hard right make decent advances. After Joe Biden’s weak attempt to debate Donald Trump on Thursday, and the Democrats’ refusal to offer voters a different candidate, the chances that Trump will re-enter the White House have increased.
When I asked Keir Starmer last week what he thought about a Marine Le Pen victory, he said he wanted “progressives” to win across Europe. Starmer’s preference is clear. But that does not mean Labour will not work with nationalist governments. As Jason writes in this week’s cover story, David Lammy’s foreign policy is to engage with governments whatever their ideological purity. He has spent time with senior Republicans, such as vice-president contender JD Vance, Senator Lindsey Graham and the former secretary of state Mike Pompeo. I’m told to expect similar treatment of nationalist governments in Europe.
The early parliamentary election took Labour by surprise as much as Macron’s own prime minister, who was reportedly furious with the rash decision. Lammy has invested time building relationships with Macron’s inner circle (as I reported here). But France’s next elections weren’t due until 2027, meaning outreach to Macron’s potential successors has been minimal. Expect, therefore, Labour to extend overtures to Le Pen’s National Rally soon.
That may not be as difficult as you might think. Key to Labour’s plans for Europe is to agree a security pact. Le Pen has indicated in the past her support for the Lancaster House Agreement, which binds the UK and France together over defence. Le Pen’s move to moderate the party – she’s distanced herself from Germany’s more extreme Alternative for Germany, for instance – makes cooperation easier.
If Starmer wins on Thursday, he could soon face nationalist governments across the Channel and the Atlantic. Five days after the election, he would attend (if he wins) the Nato summit in Washington DC. Two weeks after the election, at Blenheim Palace, Starmer would host the European Political Community, a Macron initiative that facilitates EU engagement with the UK. Both summits are opportunities for Labour to kick-start its planned “reset” in relations with Europe. A turbulent election in France will only make this mission more important.
Freddie’s picks
In a few years’ time, Reform could pose a bigger threat to Labour than the Conservatives. I went on the road with Nigel Farage’s party to find out why.
Rachel goes inside the shadow Tory party leadership contest.
The professor of politics Jonathan White criticises Labour’s missions for lacking ideology.
Jonn Elledge, our resident Tory-media watcher, thinks the right-wing press has gone into meltdown.
Mailshot
Guardian: England make last-minute recovery against Slovakia
FT: Morgan Stanley to join Goldman and JPMorgan in scrapping UK bonus cap
David Remnick: The reckoning of Joe Biden
Rogers & Baker: Biden’s family tells him to keep fighting
Hugh Schofield: Le Pen’s party now dominant force in France
Rana Foroohar: CEOs in the age of anxiety
Patrick Wintour: Lammy must signal how the UK will reconnect with the world
Kenber & Kennedy: How young Starmer made his name as a radical barrister
Hurdler Alaysha Johnson makes it to Olympics in borrowed shoes and self-designed uniform
Ben’s take
Welcome to polling week – the most exciting/exhausting week of the year for campaigners and commentators alike.
The probability is that the Conservatives will experience a defeat unseen in the party’s history. But we need to be clear about this – while all models point to such a defeat, the scale is varied. Polling and forecasting are a science. Numbers are proper but not entire. There is always a range of reasonable probability. The Britain Predicts model says the Conservatives could come away with upwards of 167 seats, and as few as 17 seats. The election on Thursday has, on paper at least, a result of 167 Tory seats just as likely as a result of 17 seats. It sounds ridiculous. But in enough locales it is that close. It is that uncertain.
Reform is an error margin and a bit out in more than a dozen parliamentary seats. If everyone works out the way some pollsters are saying, and the Conservative base splits 30 per cent or more to Reform (as YouGov suggests), then Nigel Farage’s scrambled gamble will have handsomely paid off, and they will finish with more than a dozen seats.
There is your margin of error: a Tory defeat on a scale we have never seen before, or a defeat similar to 1997. Take your pick.
And with that…
I saw Joe Penhall’s new play The Constituent on Friday night at London’s Old Vic theatre (Jason also went to see it). James Corden plays an anguished ex-serviceman whose relationship with his local MP, played by Anna Maxwell Martin, turns dark. The reviews are mixed. I thought Corden’s performance, particularly his final monologue, was brilliant. Go see it.
Let me know what you think about today’s Morning Call by hitting reply.
Have a great day,
Freddie — @freddiejh8